Episodes
Ep. 91: The Amityville Horror, Pt. 2 - The Haunting
In the second of our two-part series on the best-known, most widely dramatized haunting case in American History, we finally get …
Ep. 90: The Amityville Horror, Pt. 1 - Murder on Ocean Avenue
The Amityville Horror is one of the most publicized hauntings in American history. But 13 months before the Lutz family's short a…
Ep. 89: Slender Man, Pt. 2 - The Slender Man Stabbing
On part two of our two-part Slender Man series, we dive into the very real consequences of this modern legend of a monster with t…
Ep. 88: Slender Man, Pt. 1 - The Origins
Is it possible for an online meme-turned-urban legend to become...real? That's the question we ask this week as we investigate th…
Ep. 87: The Stamford Bra Murders
Between 1967 and 1971, the small city of Stamford, Connecticut was terrorized by a little-known serial killer. A total of five Bl…
Ep. 86: Cursed Jewelry
Among the legends of allegedly cursed objects, stories of cursed jewelry and gemstones reign supreme. There's something mystical …
Ep. 85: The Guillotine and the Reign of Terror
Even among all the creative execution methods mankind has dreamed up over the years, the Guillotine stands out, raising nightmare…
Ep. 84: The Disappearance of Amy Lynn Bradley
In March 1998, the Bradley family - dad Ron, mom Iva, son Brad, and daughter Amy - embarked on a "trip of a lifetime": a luxuriou…
Ep. 83: The Philadelphia Experiment
This week we dive into one of the most persistent legends of secret U.S. military experimentation - the famed Philadelphia Experi…
Ep. 82: TV Mysteries - The Max Headroom Incident & Other Signal Hijac…
In November 1987, one of the weirdest moments of TV history happened right underneath the noses of the Chicago viewing public. Th…
Ep. 81: Blackbeard
Inspired by the new hit show "Our Flag Means Death", we're covering the most famous pirate in history: Blackbeard! At the dawn of…
Ep. 80: Fresno Nightcrawlers
After a long month of axe-murder mayhem, Carrie takes a break from the grim and gory to tell a strange tale about what may be the…
Ep. 79: Axe Murder Fever, Pt. 4 - The Cross-Country Murders
Axe Season 2022 comes to a close with the end of our discussion of Bill and Rachel James' 'Man From The Train' theory. We follow …
Ep. 78: Axe Murder Fever, Pt. 3 - The Man from the Train
We’re rounding out Axe Murder Month with two weeks on Sean’s favorite solution to last week’s unsolved mystery, the 1912 axe murd…
Ep. 77: Axe Murder Fever, Pt. 2 - The Villisca Axe Murders
Sometime in the overnight hours of June 9-10, 1912 in the tiny town of Villisca, Iowa, eight people - including six children - we…
Ep. 76: Axe Murder Fever, Pt. 1 - The Axeman of New Orleans
Sean has officially declared March to be axe murder month - much to the chagrin of March-born Carrie - and so we begin a multi-pa…
Ep. 75: The Hauntings of Union Cemetery
Union Cemetery sits at a crossroads, almost 400 years old, with headstones scattered across its area spanning centuries of New En…
Ep. 74: Ghost Ships, Pt. 2
We're singin' more sea shanties on the finale to our 2-part series on ghost ships! This week Sean rounds things out with two twen…
Ep. 73: Ghost Ships, Pt. 1
In this first of two nautical episodes, Sean introduces us to three of history’s eeriest ghost ships. First, the Flying Dutchm…
Ep. 72: The Day the Music Died
"A long, long time ago, I can still remember..." February 3rd, 1959. Three of the brightest stars in the rock 'n roll galaxy - Bu…
Ep. 71: Herb Baumeister
This week we take a look at Indiana's most prolific serial killer, Herb Baumeister. After a string of disappearances of gay men …
Ep. 70: Flat Earth
In the incredibly polarized times we're living in, it's comforting to know there are some things we can all agree on, even if it'…
Ep. 69: The Winchester Mystery House
In 1886, Sarah Winchester - widow of William Winchester, the son of the founder of the Winchester Repeating Arms Company - took h…
Ep. 68: The Strange Death of Edgar Allan Poe
In October 1849, now-legendary horror and suspense writer Edgar Allan Poe was found in a tavern in Baltimore, delirious, with clo…